How AI Works
AI generates its responses through sorting through large quantities of data on the internet. This can include websites, novels, blogs, and sites like Facebook. This is a 1000-foot view of what AI does and is not meant to minimize the technology. However, understanding the
basics is important to answer whether one should use AI to generate an estate plan.
Why This matters?
An estate plan is among the most personal legal endeavors a person will take. That’s because it is highly individualized and rarely are two estates the same. Clients have various intentions for how they want their estate to be distributed, often not based on what would seem logical, but instead on very personal beliefs. Clients also vary on how they want their estate handled if they are incapacitated for example, or how their pets are to be cared for, end-of-life decisions, and the list goes on and on. While an AI or software program can ask some of these questions, they will not read a client like an experienced attorney who will proactively investigate and inquire.
For these reasons, AI often struggles with answering highly individualized questions. This is because AI thrives on generalizations since it gathers its data in the aggregate. This can be even more of a concern if the user is not savvy with AI. It’s often said in AI communities that an AI is only as good as the questions it's asked.
AI Accuracy
I’d bet most users vastly different testimony regarding AI accuracy. Some may point to different AI versions or programs having varying levels of accuracy. Based on my experience, the accuracy is often correlated with the subject matter. The more general question, the more
precise. Legal nuisances, partly grey areas, are where I have noticed the most struggles with AI accuracy.
Like most of you, I’d wager that AI will become more accurate with time. However, will it ever be accurate enough to bet your estate on? I say this because even if an AI is 99% accurate, it may be that 1% that makes the difference. Remember that AI owes you no legal duty whereas an attorney is accountable for their work.
What Can’t AI Do
Estate planning is more than the simple creation of legal documents. Some actions require a person with legal knowledge to administer an estate plan. Examples include creating and recording a deed, along with the other supplement documents that are required to be manually filled out. Another example is assigning an LLC to a trust or transferring a mobile home to a trust. Countless other actions would require action by an actual person, depending on the estate plan. Even with advancements in AI, this will not be possible.
Other AI Concerns
AI, like other tools on the internet, is suspectable to date/privacy breaches. This is even more concerning because data related to your estate plan is particularly sensitive, often documenting the most intimate aspects of your life. On a similar note, AI is in its infancy stage and things could change in the future. In the legal world, there are concerns as to the method of how AI gathers data. That is, it gathers data from other people's information on the internet. It's unknown how these copywriting concerns will change AI, if at all, in the future
Recommended AI Uses
In the legal field, AI can be useful to get baseline knowledge of a legal question or concept. Like a Google search, but often with more precision as it directly answers your question. An internet favorite prompt is to ask an AI to explain a difficult legal concept as if you were 12 years old (or younger). However, take caution, because AI is still very inaccurate.
I recommend you find an AI that can check the source of its answer. The legal questions I have asked AI are often incorrect. If it's an important legal question that you intend to rely on, I would not rely on AI or the source the AI gets the information because of the amount of misinformation on the internet. Your best bet would be verifying the information with an attorney who is accountable to you or an authoritative source, such as a legal statute that you are comfortable interpreting.
Summary
Since estate planning is highly individualized, it may struggle with an individual's unique situation given the way AI gathers its data from the internet. While AI will advance with time, it may be some time (if ever) when AI will be able to be accurate enough that a person would gamble their estate with, given that AI is not accountable for its answers. Perhaps most overlooked for estate planning is what actions need to be taken for proper estate plan administration. Even with AI advancement, it will not be able to navigate the bureaucracy that requires the manual filing of paperwork or coordinating with other entities like notaries or CPAs, among the many other actions that require a human to complete. Therefore, I would not recommend you use AI to draft an estate plan.